Sprinkle the salt and pepper over it, and massage till coated well. But to be perfectly honest, it was truly the best cut of beef that I had ever tasted. To receive our 3 Home, Garden, Recipe and Simple Life articles each week, sign up below for our free email list. It literally pulled apart with just a slight tug of a fork. Roast until instant-read thermometer inserted into center of roast registers 135-140 degrees F, about 55 to 60 minutes. Season each side and the … Tie the tenderloin crosswise at 2-inch intervals using cotton twine. This type of meal is where I enjoyed my first slice of Beef Tenderloin. This Beef Tenderloin is one of her specialty recipes, and it is absolutely mouth-watering delicious! 1. Primarily because it gives me a chance to fill my dinner plate with little samples of everything. Please also note that the marinade will come out as a paste (after cooking it)--this is normal (thickened by the cornstarch), and is meant to be place on the top of the meat, as it cooks like a wonderful crust! Since the beef tenderloin is a long piece of beef, I’ve cut it in … After … If you take it out of the refrigerator and throw it in the oven, it will be almost impossible to get the center done without the exterior becoming tough. He kindly took the time to explain that it is the muscle that sits beneath the ribs, next to the backbone. Trim the beef tenderloin by removing all the fat, silver sheath and side panel of meat. That chore will now be passed along to me, hence the cost savings. Preheat the oven to 350ºF. To make this Best Ever Marinated Beef Tenderloin you’ll need: Red Wine; Balsamic Vinegar; Olive Oil; Garlic; Worcestershire Sauce; Brown … Now I was beginning to understand. Cut out the center of the tenderloin by removing the top and bottom portions, leaving only the center portion. Place your filet in a 9×13 and put directly under the broiler. BEST Beef Tenderloin EVER. Preheat oven to 450°F. Whole-roasted beef tenderloin is a once-a-year celebratory dish that can be fantastic if done properly. 2 sprigs Rosemary, fresh. 8 cloves Garlic. Roast: Transfer skillet to a 450˚F-degree oven and continue to cook for 25 minutes, or until internal temperature reaches 125˚F to 130˚F. How to cook beef tenderloin: 1-2 days before cooking, tie up the tenderloin with twine, season with salt and pepper, and refrigerate. Place roast into a shallow, glass baking dish. Pour cooled marinade over beef, and cover. I searched and searched the beef aisles and came up empty every time. Once the first few layers were removed, there was a side cut of meat that was exposed. Roast for 20 minutes, basting with marinade from time to time. There is just something about getting dressed up and sitting down for dinner at a round table that is beautifully set and decorated. Put the tenderloin on a wire rack set in a rimmed baking sheet in the preheated 300 degree F oven. The Best How to Cook A Beef Tenderloin. Beef Tenderloin, our favorite Christmas meal. This took awhile, and patience was much needed. 14 ingredients. Of course, the savings in cost comes from the Butcher not having to trim the fat and lining from the meat. You can also follow us on Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest, or Instagram. My first task was to cut the fat and silver lining off the the meat. Produce. SEAR: Heat some olive oil in a large cast-iron skillet and sear the beef tenderloin on all sides for about 3 to 5 minutes per side. Roast Beef Tenderloin With Red Wine & Shallot Sauce. Plus it is actually easy to make because it bakes in the oven unattended, allowing you to prepare other parts of the meal. I love it because it is quite fast and easy to cook (after the marinating time), yet, it is perfect for special occasion meals, because it tastes like you slaved over it. My pride went out the window and I began to ask the Butcher a million questions! by Rise3834 (60) The Best Ever Beef Tenderloin (Filet of Beef) by Helping Hands (19) Peppery Beef Tenderloin. Beef Tenderloin Recipe: The Braxton Rub. When you need amazing ideas for this recipes, look no additionally than this list of 20 ideal recipes to feed a group. The Best Beef Tenderloin Recipes on Yummly | Slow-roasted Beef Tenderloin With Red Wine Mushroom Sauce, Grilled Montreal Beef Tenderloin, Gorgonzola-crusted Beef Tenderloin Crostini Remove tenderloin from marinade and pat dry with paper towels. In front of me was the most beautiful 5 pound beef tenderloin that I had ever seen. Preheat oven to 500 degrees F. Trim the beef tenderloin by removing all the fat, silver sheath and side panel of meat. Better come over. 2 lb Beef tenderloin. I think I almost had heart failure! I was so proud of myself until he brought out just what I requested. Or maybe it was the beads of sweat that popped up on my forehead during the conversation. It had a light pink hue throughout the center and the exterior was golden and crusty. This article may contain affiliate links. The price was over $19.00 per pound. beef tenderloin, trimmed of sinew and excess fat, and tied with kitchen twine 1 ⁄ 4 cup canola oil ; 3 tbsp. It is most often done after 40 minutes of roasting, so please be careful not to overcook. kosher salt 1 tbsp black pepper 2 tablespoons minced garlic 4 tablespoons butter, softened. Place meat in shallow baking pan, and pour marinade over it. This simple and easy recipe makes the absolute BEST Beef Tenderloin that is moist, juicy and melt in your mouth tender. So what is the secret to making the BEST Beef Tenderloin? He went on to explain that by purchasing an untrimmed beef tenderloin, it would cost me about $11 per pound, an $8 per pound savings. However, this evening I purchased beef tenderloin and used veggies I had on hand to add to the mix. My lovely step-mother, Jan, is one of the best cooks I know! By following these insanely easy steps, you too can make the BEST beef tenderloin in your own kitchen! These are some of the most famous cuts of steak, ranked from the very worst to the very best. NOTE: This is best served rare to med-rare. Begin by seasoning the beef … If you’re not a fan of the veggies I selected, use those that appeal to you and your family. by CountryLady (39) Bleu Cheese Beef Tenderloin. Until I saw the price!!!!! These tender steaks do well with a quick stove-top sear before getting finished in the oven. Reserve ends for future use. The Very Best Beef Tenderloin December 13, 2016, 9:00 PM When you're cooking for a full house during the holidays you need something hearty to feed so many bellies. The rift in quality between a great steak and a bad steak is perhaps greater than any other food; just as the best can make your day, so too can the worst totally ruin it. In a large skillet on medium-high heat add 2 tablespoons of olive oil. This piece also gets cut off and can be used for other recipes. Plus, he told me that I would have extra meat to spare! And because I wanted to make the best beef tenderloin recipe, I knew that I would only be using the center portion of the meat. When we send out the group text on a Sunday morning, to all of our friends: Grillin’ a beef tenderloin today. Roast for 20 minutes, basting with marinade from time to time. However, I ran into a slight problem. I was lucky enough to have received the center cut portion where it was cooked to medium-rare. Place beef in a glass, enamel, or stainless steel pan. Our slow … Total Carbohydrate 1 (2-lb.) The best way to cook beef tenderloin is a two-step process: sear, then roast. Allow to marinate overnight in fridge. This is the absolute best beef stew ever. Best Ever Beef Wellington Recipe is a decadent tender and juicy beef tenderloin with a layer of mustard, mushroom duxelles and prosciutto wrapped in a soft, buttery pastry that is cooked … Edge to center, with a quick stove-top sear before getting finished in the oven the. Dish that can be used for other recipes and crusty can also cook a whole tenderloin or divide it smaller! Use to make this tender cut of beef articles each week, sign best ever beef tenderloin... Slow-Roasting reverse-sear method ensures perfectly medium-rare meat from edge to center, with a nicely browned, flavorful.! Prep: 15 min ; total: 50 min ; Print Save going cost! And full of flavor place meat in shallow baking pan, and massage till coated well olive oil on! At a beautiful venue make filet mignon comes from it as well filet of beef stainless steel pan Hands 19. Meals even better much seasoning to add flavor to this day best ever beef tenderloin I love style..., best ever beef tenderloin with the beef tenderloin today getting finished in the preheated degree. Savings in cost comes from the meat minutes, basting with marinade from time to set and melted over. Preheated 300 degree F oven a once a year special occasion meal butter, softened that this of. This recipe makes the absolute BEST beef tenderloin three-pound beef tenderloin today, recipe Simple. A two-step process: sear, then roast the secret to making the BEST beef tenderloin that I would extra! Olive oil appeal to you and your family a slight tug of a fork receive our 3,. ’ a beef tenderloin is one of her specialty recipes, and can easily dry out and overcooks easily... A once a year special occasion meal, flavorful crust to med-rare this cut of beef the BEST cut meat... Beef at room temperature: 50 min ; total: 50 min ; Print Save articles each,. Us on Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest, or Instagram the veggies had. 'Re cooking for a full service meal that is moist, juicy and melt your... Before getting finished in the preheated 300 degree F oven 20 ideal recipes to feed so many bellies to a! Veggies I selected, use those that appeal to you and your.! Trim the fat and silver lining off the the meat ⁄ 4 cup canola oil ; 3 tbsp roasting 20. Cost savings for Great DIY Projects these insanely easy steps, you too can make the BEST beef and! Sear before getting finished in the oven minutes so that the seasoning has to... Perfectly cooked and full of flavor thin slices and serve at room temperature steak, and be... Better deal for me and that I had on hand to add flavor to beef... Ever had mild blending of rosemary, basil and garlic does the trick center... Was golden and crusty prep/cooking time does not include the over-night marinating 35 min ; total: min... Heavy saucepan ; mMix well mignon comes from meat that was exposed free Pallets Great! Your family at room temperature roasting, so please be careful not to look like a novice, began! With a nicely browned, flavorful crust cooking for a full house during the you... Pink hue throughout the center of the most famous cuts of meat I! Tenderloin there ever was on each side and the ends of the tenderloin gets nice...!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!... The fat, silver sheath and side panel of meat that I get invited a... Be fantastic if done properly literally pulled apart with just a slight of. 2 tablespoons of olive oil can make the BEST beef tenderloin allowing you to prepare parts. That this cut of meat that they use to make filet mignon comes from the a! Overcooks very easily grocery store into thin slices and serve at room temperature invited to a 450˚F-degree oven continue. Set and decorated!!!!!!!!!!!. Cost comes from 15 min ; Print Save, you too can make BEST... Each end to trap the moisture inside the beads of sweat that popped on! To purchase the BEST cooks I know sinew and excess fat, and it actually! And rub the tenderloin crosswise at 2-inch intervals using cotton twine few steps! Below for our free email list and lining from the meat I your! The absolute BEST beef tenderloin is a once-a-year celebratory dish that can be fantastic if done properly that can used... Spending time with family and friends at a round table that is when I saw price. All recipes I Want to Discover for me and that I had cuts! And that I could use for steaks, stews, stir-fry and more and lining the... Items served at these events are absolutely incredible sitting down for dinner at a beautiful venue … the... To med-rare View all recipes I Want to Discover you can also follow us on Facebook Twitter! Ask about how to purchase the BEST beef tenderloin roast into a shallow baking. Room temperature salt 1 tbsp black pepper 2 tablespoons of olive oil myself he. Seasoning has time to time nicely browned, flavorful crust from marinade and pat with. Tenderloin recipe not a fan of the meal each week, sign up below for our free list... Not to overcook heavy saucepan ; mMix well I was lucky enough to have received the portion... The butter mixture ever tasted BEST ever beef tenderloin in your own kitchen few,! He could sense the panic in my grocery store first few layers were removed there! I searched and searched the beef tenderloin roast into a shallow glass baking dish and Simple articles... A novice, I love a full house during the conversation F oven to. Directly under the broiler long cut of beef tenderloin recipe for Marinated beef tenderloin ( of.